Leading a team
How to tell an employee they didn't get the promotion
Tell them in person before the announcement, explain why with concrete examples and agree on what they'd need to show next time.
Build your opening script
Your message
What you type stays in your browser: we don't store it or send it anywhere.
Before you write
- Have concrete examples of what was missing.
- Tell them before the public announcement.
- Prepare a development plan with deadlines.
All three tones, with an example
Taylor, I wanted to tell you before the announcement: this time you weren't selected for the Team Lead role. I know you put a lot into this and I value it. I want to share what was missing and build a plan so you're ready next time.
Taylor, you won't be getting the promotion to Team Lead this cycle. I'll explain why with concrete examples, and what you need to develop for the next opportunity.
Taylor, I'm letting you know the Team Lead position has been filled by someone else. The decision was based on [criteria]. We'll review your development plan in the next 30 days.
What comes next
- 1
Share the decision upfront.
- 2
Give feedback with examples.
- 3
Agree on the development plan.
- 4
Review progress monthly.
If they say…
They say“Why someone else?”
You reply“I can't discuss another person, but I can talk about what you need for that role.”
They say“I feel my work isn't recognized.”
You reply“I understand why you'd feel that way. Your work is valued; let me show you where the gap is for this role.”
They say“Okay, what do I need to improve?”
You reply“I love that you're asking. Let's build the plan together.”
What not to say
- False hope (“definitely next time”)If it doesn't happen, you lose credibility.
- Comparing them to whoever was chosenIt creates conflict.
- Letting them find out from the announcementThey deserve to hear it first.
FAQ
How do I tell them without crushing their motivation?
Honestly, with concrete feedback and a plan with deadlines.
Do I have to explain why someone else was chosen?
Focus on their development, not comparisons.
What if they want to leave?
Listen, and show them the concrete path they have internally.
Similar situations
- How to tell an employee there's no raise this yearSay it early and in person, explain the real reason in a sentence or two and offer something concrete: a plan, a review date or recognition.
- How to give negative feedback to an employeeDo it soon and in private. Describe a specific fact and its impact, listen, and close with an agreement and a review date.
- How to ask for a promotionAsk for a meeting, bring evidence you're already doing part of the role you want and ask what's missing to get there, with a date.
Updated: